Potbelly Menu Prices

Last updated: October 2026 · Prices cross-checked from thirstybear.com and everymenuprices.com (2026 pricing); calorie figures from Potbelly's published nutrition data via sixstoreys.com cross-checks. Prices vary by location and by size (Skinny / Original / Big); soup flavors rotate by day.

Potbelly is a Chicago-founded sandwich shop known for sandwiches served hot off the grill, with live music at many locations. Sandwiches come in Skinny, Original, and Big sizes, and the menu also covers salads, soups, shakes, and baked cookies.

Quick answer: The cheapest full-size bite is a cup of soup or mac & cheese at about $6.29. A typical Original sandwich lunch with chips and a drink runs $13-$17.

Potbelly Prices at a Glance

Cheapest item: Mac & Cheese (cup) — $6.29
Most expensive: Prime Rib Cheesesteak (Original) — $13.99
Average combo: $14.59
Best value pick: Pick Your Pair — Skinny Sandwich + Cup of Salad (~$14.39)

Signature Sandwiches

Item	Price	Calories	Description
A Wreck	$10.99 – $12.99	730	The fan favorite: turkey, ham, roast beef, salami and Swiss stacked together.
Italian	$9.99 – $11.99	639	Capicola, mortadella, pepperoni and salami with provolone and Italian seasoning.
Turkey Breast	$9.49 – $11.49	467	Hand-sliced turkey breast with Swiss and your choice of fresh toppings.
Avo Turkey	$10.99 – $13.69		Turkey with fresh-sliced avocado and cucumbers.
Chicken Club	$10.99 – $12.99	692	Grilled chicken with applewood smoked bacon, cheddar and ranch.
BLTA	$10.99 – $11.79	583	The classic BLT upgraded with creamy avocado.
Roast Beef	$9.99 – $11.99	498	Thinly sliced roast beef with provolone and a punch of horseradish mayo.
Veggie Melt	$8.99 – $10.99	525	Mushrooms, peppers and onions melted with provolone — surprisingly filling.
Grilled Chicken	$10.99 – $12.99	470	Grilled chicken breast with cheddar and fresh veggies.
Tuna Salad	$8.99 – $10.99	577	Classic house-made tuna salad with Swiss and crunchy veggies.
Chicken Salad	$8.99 – $10.99		Creamy chicken salad with Swiss and fresh toppings.
Cubano	$10.99 – $12.99		Slow-cooked pork, ham, Swiss, deli mustard and pickles — the Miami-style sandwich.
BBQ Pulled Pork	$10.99 – $12.99		Slow-cooked pulled pork with cheddar, pickles and sweet-heat BBQ sauce.
Prime Rib Cheesesteak	$11.99 – $13.99		Tender prime rib with Swiss, caramelized onions and garlic aioli — the premium pick.
Meatball	$9.99 – $11.99	745	Italian meatballs with marinara and melted provolone.
Pizza Sandwich	$9.49 – $11.49	668	Pepperoni, provolone and marinara — pizza flavors in sandwich form.
Mediterranean	$9.49 – $10.99	440	Veggie-packed sandwich with hummus and feta — the lightest option.
Smoked Ham	$8.99 – $10.99	512	Smoked ham with Swiss on toasted bread.
Grilled Cheese	$7.79 – $8.99	488	Childhood favorite served adult-sized on grilled bread.

Salads

Item	Price	Description
Farmhouse Salad	$9.39	The classic Potbelly salad with grilled chicken and farmhouse fixings.
Apple Walnut Salad	$9.39	Crisp apple and walnut over fresh greens.
Powerhouse Salad	$9.39	A hearty protein-packed salad with grilled chicken.

Pick Your Pair

Item	Price	Calories	Description
Skinny Sandwich + Cup of Salad	$14.39		A skinny sandwich plus a cup of salad — two favorites, one price.
Half Salad + Cup of Salad	$14.59		Half salad with a cup of salad for a lighter combo.

Mac & Soups

Item	Price	Description
Mac & Cheese	$6.29	Creamy baked mac and cheese, a comfort-food staple.
Chicken Pot Pie Soup	$6.29	Thick chicken pot pie soup with a flaky-style richness.
Chili	$6.29	Beef chili with beans, served hot.
Broccoli Cheddar Soup	$6.29	Broccoli and cheddar in a creamy cheese soup.
Garden Vegetable Soup	$6.29	Light garden vegetables in a savory broth.
Loaded Baked Potato Soup	$6.29	Baked-potato-style soup with bacon and cheddar flavors.

Cookies & Shakes

Item	Price	Description
Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookie	$2.89	The classic cookie with oatmeal and chocolate chips.
Sugar Cookie	$2.89	Simple sweet sugar cookie, baked fresh in-store.
Chocolate Brownie Cookie	$2.89	Rich fudge-style chocolate brownie cookie.
Dream Bar	$3.19	Potbelly's signature layered dessert bar.
Chocolate Shake	$6.79	Thick hand-spun chocolate shake.
Vanilla Shake	$6.79	Classic hand-spun vanilla shake.
Strawberry Shake	$6.29	Strawberry shake made thick and creamy.
OREO Cookie Shake	$7.19	OREO cookie pieces blended into vanilla ice cream.

Sides & Drinks

Item	Price	Description
Zapp's Regular Chips	$2.59	A bag of kettle-cooked Zapp's chips to go with your sandwich.
Whole Pickle	$1.69	A whole crunchy pickle spear — the classic sandwich sidekick.
Fountain Drink	$4.29	Fountain soda served over ice.

Popular at Potbelly

A Wreck $10.99 – $12.99 The signature sandwich — four meats plus Swiss, the most-ordered item on the menu.

Italian $9.99 – $11.99 The classic Italian sub done Potbelly-style: hot, toasted, and loaded with pepperoni and capicola.

Turkey Breast $9.49 – $11.49 The lighter go-to — hand-sliced turkey at 467 calories for those watching intake.

OREO Cookie Shake $7.19 A thick hand-spun shake that regulars say rivals any ice cream shop.

Potbelly Menu FAQs

What is the cheapest thing at Potbelly?

The cheapest full-size item is a cup of soup or mac & cheese at about $6.29. The Skinny Pair deal (soup + skinny sandwich) runs around $6.80-$7.99 where still offered.

How much is a typical Potbelly lunch?

An Original-size signature sandwich runs $9-$13 depending on the sandwich and location, plus $2.59 for chips and a drink. Budget around $13-$17 for a full lunch.

Do sandwich sizes change the price much?

Yes — Original is the standard size. Skinny has about a third less bread, meat and cheese for fewer calories, and Big has about a third more for bigger appetites.

What is the Pick Your Pair deal?

Potbelly runs a Pick Your Pair menu — a Skinny sandwich plus a cup of salad, or a half salad plus a cup of salad, for about $14-$16. It is the best-priced way to try two things.

Which Potbelly sandwich has the fewest calories?

The Mediterranean sandwich is the lightest option at about 440 calories. For under 500, try Turkey Breast (467), Grilled Chicken (470), or Grilled Cheese (488).

Prices may vary by location.